Showing posts with label Open Source. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Open Source. Show all posts

Thursday, 19 January 2017

OS Readings Series: Avery

Avery, Joshua M., ‘Implementing an Open Source Integrated Library System (ILS) in a Special Focus Institution’, Digital Library Perspectives, 32 (2016), 287

These notes have turned into a list of advice... the start of the article contains a very nice literature review on similar projects, and observations about same.


  • A list of ILS selction criteria are listed in Bossels 2008, Muller 2011, Pruett and Choi 2013. Sing and Sanamann 2012 and Yang and Hofmann 2010
  • Current literature shows Koha is a better fit for small less complex library systems. 
  • Opac is highly customizable
  • Discussions with local IT began well in advance of migration. A task management system (Asana) was put in place (manage, schedule, track and update stages)
  • Knowledge gathering via listserv, chat-boards, weblogs, tutorials, documentation and contacts
  • Read online handbook 
  • Talk to institutions of same size
  • Test server allow release and updates to be tested before going live
  • Koha implementation check list is available online
  • Install than, branches, item types, patron types, collections. Locations and other rules and preferences > then data migration
  • Migration means questioning rules, config., etc. 
  • Data mapping > MARC EDIT USED to edit marc records for import
    • 952 = holdings data
    • 942 = class and item type
    • Data is loaded in batches so carefully label each batch using the comment function in the koha batch upload tool 
    • Try to keep batches <10,000
    • Batch load Circ data via offline circ
  • One month before live = final opac customizations and intensive training for staff on new system
  • Old system was kept live for 24 months and staff did harvest data from it on occasion. 
  • Each library’s migration and day to day experience is different.  
  • Consider formal per and post measures of staff and student satisfaction with the ILS
  • Local understanding of the limits of MySQL, CSS, HTML, Linux, Apache and Perl is needed
  • Clearly determine who is responsible for which task
  • Waive fines and fees
  • Have regular meetings with all parties – face to face


OS Readings Series: Singh

Singh, Vandana, ‘Experiences of Migrating to an Open- Source Integrated Library System’, Information Technology & Libraries, 32 (2013), 36–53 <http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=89093583&site=eds-live> [accessed 19 January 2017] 
Singh refers to Kohn and McCloy's advice to migrate in 3 phases: 

  1.  Public Web Site and Federated Catalogue
  2. & 3 Staff back end. 
In relation to time frames Walls (3 months) and Dennison and Lewis ( 2months) are mentioned. 

Advice is given to have staff work on the system before training (2 days), to ensure that they get the most out of it, and to deliver same by module.

CONSIDERATIONS outlined: 
  • Create awareness as to what open source is in the library
  • Develop IT skills internally
  • Have a demonstration system
  • Have a designated liaison with the vendor
  • Set aside a significant amount of staff time for: 
    • Testing
    • Development
    • Migration
  • Set up regular meetings
  • Do three test loads
  • Set up tables and settings in advance
  • Do data mapping very carefully
  • Weed out of date materials 
  • Have a fine amnesty
  • Look at grant money for OS development and do so in a partnership.
  • Spot check data
  • Utilise training materials generated by other libraries 
  • Utilise manuals created by other libraries
  • Utilise pre-existing webinars
  • Systems administration staff will need more intensive training
    • Specifically: Linux and SQL
  • If migration is changing things significantly for patrons additional marketing and a demonstration system could be made available
  • Set up online tutorials for patrons 

Open source systems for libraries - readings series

Over the next while I will be doing a significant amount of reading in the area of open source systems for libraries. My notes on each reading (including full citation) will be posted separately on this blog, and these notes will be from the perspective of looking to implement some of these systems. Each reading will be listed here once posted. The readings will be from a variety of sources, from blogs, wiki's, journals etc.



Wednesday, 27 August 2014

DBS Annual Library Seminar 2014 - Part 1 (June 2014)

This is the blog post for the first three sessions of the DBS Annual Library Seminar. See the next post for the second three sessions

Agenda for the seminar: 

10:00 – 11:00        Gary Brewerton and Marie O’Neill | The Reading List Challenge: Implementing Loughborough
                                 Online Reading List Software (LORLS)

11:00 – 11:45        Dr Clare Thornley | The Role of Librarians in Measuring the Impact of Research


12:00 – 12:30        Brian Hickey | The Opportunities and Challenges of Hosting on the Cloud

12:30 – 13:00        Alexander Kouker | DBS Assignment Planner and Reference Tracking


13:45 – 14:15        David Hughes | Migration to the Koha Open Source LMS: The DBS Library Experience

14:15 – 14:45        Maria Rogers and Keith Brittle | The Benefits of Cross-Institutional Collaboration

Implementing Loughborough Online Reading List Software (LORLS)

Marie O'Neill

As reading list evaluation is part of course accreditation DBS  Library wanted to use the course reading lists as a stock control mechanism, as an unfulfilled or unavailable reading list item can prompt student disengagement. Online reading lists move students towards being autonomous readers, especially when links to the library system via a reading list system, or VLE (Moodle), leads to spontaneous resource discovery. 

Moving reading lists from a paper basis to on online basis became a library project. Reading Lists are the student's first encounter with academic life. 
Usage analytics are useful. Book records with the course code are too, as are the capacity to import/export into and out of Moodle but it does not create a unified / central location for this information for students and academics. Therefore on online solution was sought at DBS. 

Reading lists softwares were investigated.
LORLS, matched the need of the library and the assessment criteria, with additional functions like the ability to import / export via Zotero. This allows the system to be pre-populated with data, which can then be maintained by the Academics going forward. 
See the publications of Gary Brewerton for more information. 

Gary Brewerton

The term reading list implies an academic tie, however there are many different structures that are used for delivering these lists, partly because they differ in size, and vary by discipline, with Arts being more reading intensive than Engineering and Science. 

Issues; 
  • Student unable to locate materials on a reading list 
  • Academics don't know if or how to use them leading to demotivation
  • Library's are often not informed of the materials required, possibly never seeing the list at all. 
  • Institutional reputation may suffer if the reading materials are not available. 
  • Browsing is the first year default search methods for reading materials. 

LORLS has been around since 2002 and has gone through several re-development cycles. 
Developments have included:
  • Add a link to Google Books if the materials are out of copyright 
  • Administrators ability to un-delete reading lists
  • Support for the Harvard Citation Style
  • Academic users can sort, comment, create a subheading, see how the list is used on the dashboard
    • Getting Academics to participate is an issue
  • Library can see content types, and book borrowing data
  • Items liked and not-liked
  • Items can be flagged to the librarian's if they are not held int he library's collections
  • E-mail alerts can be created when an item is added
  • Reports can indicate where a list has not been updated as expected
  • Purchasing predictor to suggest items for purchase - can tie into the LMS for budget availability. 
See the website and blog: http://blog.lboro.ac.uk/lorls/

Why DBS choose LORLS

  • Open source > cheaper, flexible,adheres to standards. 
  • Develop prestige > funding applications
  • Insight from other users 
  • Know going to tender for LMS in two years 

Project at DBS

Started in September 2013. 
Takes time to embed. 
Lots of advocacy needed, both from the library and Academic 'Champions'.

The Role of Librarians in Measuring the Impact of Research

Dr. Clare Thornley

What is research? 

  • Original Contribution 
  • Method 
  • Test theory
  • Fill a gap 
  • Investigate
  • Create new knowledge
What is impact?
  • Citation
  • Production 
  • Change in known knowledge or behaviour
  • Discourse
  • Academic Pubication
Citation indexes
  • Less than 30% of Social Science are cited. 
  • Connects an identity across all their publications.
  • Citation can be related to successful funding applications and promotions
    • Political aspect 
  • Bibliometrics use citations 
  • Altmetrics do too
Issues: 
  • Tracking downloads
    • Metrics for Institutional repositories are in isolation. 
  • Not publishing in peer-reviewed journals
  • Journals not getting cited
Aim to get into a highly cited journal. Identify these using tools like Web of Science / Knowledge. Science Watch, Publish or Perish, and Google Scholar.

The Opportunities and Challenges of Hosting on the Cloud

To me this was the best / most relevant presentation of the day and really helped me bring together the pieces of the cloud puzzle that I was already familiar with. 

Cloud computing - What to look for. 
Sotrage location not too far away from your base. 
Location transparency (ie you know where your data / app / information is going to be physcially located) 
Consult with you local IT Department 
Consult a legal expert in the area, especially in relation to  data protection and the protection of intellectual property. 
Be aware the EU law on this area is changing and will likely continue to change for a while. 

AWS (Amazon Web Services) claim to be capable of setting up from scratch in 17 minutes. It tool Brian 9 hours with a lot of background problems to get to that point. 

The Deloitte Risk Intelligence map indicates that governance and who actually has ownership are two major concerns to be addressed when moving to cloud storage or cloud computing. The factors listed here should be considered when undertaking a cloud project. 

NIST have defined cloud computing in a 3 page document which is available at: 
http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/nistpubs/800-145/SP800-145.pdf

5-3-2 principle of cloud computing 











Friday, 30 May 2014

LIR Seminar - Headlines (March 2014) - PART 1

My previous post about the LIR Seminar was focused on my presentation 'Open Source for Libraries: feel the fear and do it anyway", but here are the headlines from the other presentations.



LIR HEAnet User Group for Libraries

2014 Annual Seminar

Pride and Prejudice: the Challenges with Open Access and Open Source
Friday, March 21st
Trinity College Dublin School of Nursing and Midwifery
D'Olier Street Dublin 2.

PROGRAMME - WITH LINKS TO PRESENTATIONS AND VIDEO

Morning Session Keynote: Niamh Brennan, TCD
Jim Foran, Institute Librarian IT Sligo and Meave Mc Cauley, Acting Institute Librarian LYIT.

Glenn Wearen, HEAnet
Helen Fallon, NUI Maynooth and Anne O’Brien, Kairos Communications
Yvonne Desmond, Dublin Institute of Technology


Scott Wilson, OSSWatch, Oxford University.
Niamh Walker Headon, ITT Dublin : Institute of Technology Tallaght
David Kane, Waterford Institute of Technology

Hugh Murphy and Padraic Stack, NUI Maynooth
Jennifer Collery, University College Dublin
Lightning talks
Deirdre Judge  (slides) IADT / David Kane (slides) WIT  / Michael Ladisch, UCD (Slides)

Headlines and Highlights

Niamh Brennan

A comprehensive overview of the Irish landscape re Institutional repositories was given, starting from the first sites in 1993 to the latest projects. 

Key players and stakeholders were mentioned (ie SPARC, SPARC Europe,etc.) 

The arguments around open access were touched upon. (ie publishers campaign against the green model, freemuim etc. )

Irish policy is more in line with Berlin (EU) than Boston (USA) ( Oct. 2012 all Irish research funders support the publishing of findings in open access publications / locations. 

Focus is on getting academic on board and actively publishing using this model. This requires a change in culture for both the researcher and the libraries who support them. For example the charging of fees to publish OA has implications for some library budgets. 

COAR (Confederation of Open Access Repositories) membership is fee based and required the head of the institution sign off on membership. 

Open AIRE and Open AIRE+ allows data to be harvested which is good for visibility (CERN & Max Planx Inst.) 

Horizon 2020 is a model grant agreement

DRIVER - all university repositories
RIAN (Ireland) - OAI-PMH works with core set of data and normalization at the end of the process. 

NUIM had the 1st repository  2002.
DIT have had a policy of OA since 2003

It is of note that there is an extraordinary effort and output for such a small country. 

QUB have embedded their research information system into their institutional repository. 

The National Citation Report at the National Research Data Project 2010-3, were outlined. 

The repository network Ireland is an informal alliance formed in 2013. 

Even with all the progress made in this are it is important to remember that not all Irish research is published in an OA forum. eDeposit Ireland is voluntary deposit. Only a small number of peer reviewed articles are deposited. OA is constantly changing, creating the need for more staff and resources.
Additional types of publication are now making their way into repositories (Data sets, recordings etc.)

DART Europe is the free e-theses portal.

Issues

Confusion
Lack of awareness
Very low staffing for the repository (usually less than 1 fte)
Marketing 


Jim Foran & Meave Mc Cauley

CUAL = Connaught Ulster Alliance of Sligo IT, LKIT & GMIT. 
Created from a memorandum of understanding, co-operative projects were encouraged.
Insitutional Reposirty was selected by the libraries to put forward. Upon success BioMed Central won the tender for provision, using a Dublin Core Schema, based on DSpace and CC license. 

The challenge is to get academics and researchers to self archive. 
The next step is to get the data into RIAN.


Glenn Wearen


Outlined network tools used at HEANet and that some are for niche purposes, therefore when the best fit is Open Source Software (OSS) then that is what is used as they have an expensive physical network to maintain. 
Services offered by HEAnet include hosting in a LAMP environment, SSL certs (djangora), Vidoe Conferencing (GNU - Gate Keeper), EDURoam (free RADIUS),EDUgate (JAGGER) 
HEAnet HAVE 1.5 DEVELOPERS AND CODE IS POSTED TO GITHUB. 

Their ftp server hosts 1,000's of projects

Some selection criteria 

  • Do the staff have the skills required
  • Will those staff be retained long term
  • Is there 3rd party expertise available (trusted)
  • Total cost of ownership (license & staff V Staff & Staff skills etc) 
  • Do you need technical staff to run it 
  • Is the code well maintained, is there a development road map 
  • Is it well supported (community support is acceptable)
  • Do you need physical hardware (or can you use visualization)
  • Are open standards used > inter-operability (OS/Commercial/Cloud)
  • Which is the best solution?
  • If closed then make sure it uses an open standard.
  • Does it meet procurement rules
  • Is the required infrastructure viable.


Helen Fallon & Dr. Anne O'Brien

Spoke about the archive and recordings around Ken Saro Wiwa and Sr. Majella McCarron. 
Zoom recorder and audacity were recommended for anyone looking to create / capture audio. 
Before you begin such a project read around it to discover best practice, and tie into students who may already have the skills required. Record everything, and edit afterwards. 

Soundcloud was selected as a hosting solution as the final files were very large. (1st 2 hours are free, c.$100 annually for unlimited space). It provides statistics, comments, posting, sharing, tagging and images as album cover.The British Library are using  it for sound recordings. It can be embedded in blogger. 
Sound Cloud is a temporary solution until the archive is relocated to the Digital Repository of Ireland. 


Yvonne Desmond

Repositories give academics freedom, this is why the have held their ground. 
Institutional support in the from of Institute level mandates and funder mandates are elements needed for success. 
There are many platforms, some are easier. DIT use Digital Commons, as it has a holistic approach, and aggregates around subjects. Therefore there are no dead ends and no barriers. 

Provide access to the OA content of 321 Universities, fulfilling the promise of OA and ensuring serendipity. 
This increases the exposure of the organizations research content as it bridges from local to global content by leveraging browsable taxonomies. 

Users can follow popular articles, institutions, authors etc. 
It can be used to identify peers. 

It is totally full text, with mostly journal articles and aiming for +1 million articles by the end of 2014. 


SEE MORE IN PART 2


Friday, 4 April 2014

LIR Seminar 2014 (Headlines) PART 2 (Afternoon)

My previous post about the LIR Seminar was focused on my presentation 'Open Source for Libraries: feel the fear and do it anyway", but here are the headlines from the other presentations.



LIR HEAnet User Group for Libraries

2014 Annual Seminar

Pride and Prejudice: the Challenges with Open Access and Open Source
Friday, March 21st
Trinity College Dublin School of Nursing and Midwifery
D'Olier Street Dublin 2.

PROGRAMME - WITH LINKS TO PRESENTATIONS AND VIDEO

Scott Wilson, OSSWatch, Oxford University.
Niamh Walker Headon, ITT Dublin : Institute of Technology Tallaght
David Kane, Waterford Institute of Technology

Hugh Murphy and Padraic Stack, NUI Maynooth
Jennifer Collery, University College Dublin
Lightning talks
Deirdre Judge  (slides) IADT / David Kane (slides) WIT  / Michael Ladisch, UCD (Slides)

Headlines and Highlights

Scott Wilson

This talk outlined that it is not just the software license that has financial implications for an organisation, but a myrid other items arise. 

Other costs include: 
  1. Support
  2. Infrastructure (physical and virtual)
  3. Training
  4. Security
  5. Liability
  6. Upgrading 
  7. Maintenance

For publicly funded organizations it is essential that transparency of process is guaranteed.Look for OS (Open Source) projects that have vital communities, regular updates, and consider joining the project if it does.  

Sustainability should be considered when choosing software, as should risk management and a comprehensive exit strategy. 
  • Establish how you get your data out in a format that is compatible with other software and is usable.
  • Ask yourself will the software be around in 5 years' time. (Consider the long procurement cycle in HE)
    • OS data is public
    • How many commits to the software per month
    • How many contributions to the code per month
  • Avoid lock in 


User needs should be central, and a local trial of the product's usability should be undertaken during any pilot phase. Assess any software against the recognized 'best of breeds' ... you will find that OS is the market leader in some fields. UK government G-Cloud was given as an example http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_Government_G-Cloud

How do you account for OS in the procurement process? 

Make sure you are procuring within your organisations procurement policy, and establish whether OS is excluded by that policy. 

Approaches used
  1. Agnostic: Don't mention open source or closed source in you specification documents. 
  2. Equal consideration: to all options
  3. Preferential consideration: state preference will be given to OS solutions. 

The Process

Shallow engagement > Mature OS, customize locally 
Deep engagement: contribute back to the project, lead how the project is developed. 

NOTE: it is hard to do a 'trial' with OS. There is often no 'vendor' behind it to set it up for testing etc. 

Engage in active pre-procurement processes. Do your own survey of the market, and identify solutions yourself to inform your procurement process. Procurement processes can be designed to include a paid discovery stage. If an OS solution looks like the beat fit then go externally for support and services at this stage. 

Un-bundling can identify bundle deficiencies. 

In Sweden a parallel purchasing model is used. Two separated competitions are run and the results of both are compared. 

Is your organisation prepared to participate in 'deep engagement' with external partners, if it is a project fit? 

Evalution

  • Should be open
  • Meritocracy
  • Open governance
  • Business case: doesn't need to create more bureaucracy. 
  • In practice are there 'people barriers' to the software's acceptance by users?
      • Are staff / users aware of the procurement?
  • Are those involved in procurement aware of the staff / user needs and abilities? 
    • Are they all aware of policy, tools and how OS works? 
    • Understanding is needed
    • Capacity is needed to deliver both of the organisation and the staff / users. 
  • Cultural alignment needs to be attained as there will be differing levels of readiness for software change. 

Niamh Walker-Headon 

See previous post: http://anleabharlannai.blogspot.ie/2014/03/open-source-software-for-libraries-feel.html

David Kane (1)

WIT institutional repository (e-prints) needed more user friendly submission form. The solution was found by workign with CalTech, to create a html form eprintshelper. 
Github was used to manage the collaborative process. It was simple to use, maintaainable and provided a single source for the php needed. Changes are vetted by the library/s before they go live. 


Hugh Murphy & Padraic Stack 

NUIM's digital archive is hosted by the Digital Repository of Ireland http://dri.ie/national-university-ireland-maynooth. 

Omeka http://omeka.org/ has recently been used to curate two exhibitions online. An advantage of this is the avoidance of  vendor lock in as Omeka is 'free and open source'. Omeka was used to re-imagine NUIM's exhibition space and reinterpret it to an online environment. It is low cost, flexible, customizable, and intuitive to use. 2 different exhibitions were delivered this way, using two different workflows, and two different install methods. It is cheap, very low risk, and maintained by an academic institution.  One hosted locally, one hosted online.
Tools, plugins and themes are all supplied. 
COINS compatible, csv import, drop box plugin, Dublin CORE extended. There were some issues with data in incorrect fields. 

The development community is quite small. There are .org (download) and .net (upload) versions. 
These can be compared at http://bitly.com/compareomekas. 


Jennifer Collery

Reused and open edutation resource (OER), the online Plagarism tutorial from ITT Dublin (IT -Tallaght), available at http://millennium.it-tallaght.ie/screens/tut.html. It complimented a VLE quiz,  

OER's can be found at Jorum, floc, google, Slideshare, youtube etc.

To reuse the tutorial local branding was applied, navigation was changed to allow the user full control, and made mobile device ready via Articulate Storyline. This was then taken a step further and translated into Irish with a narration 'As Gaeilge' supplied. 

Positives from the project include the development of collaborative links, and time efficiency. 

Deirdre Judge

The concept of the Open Lirary as per the Danish model was introduced and outlined as the library being open without staff, but with staff hours. More details are available at http://cordura.dk/en/software/products/open-library/ including an overview of the type of technology needed to deliver such a service.  


David Kane (2)

The Bookscanner, open source hardware project was outlined. A DIY book scanner project was located online,  blueprints were downloaded, and a cradle built from them. A camera etc was then installed to create a low cost book scanner. 


Michael Ladisch

The ORCID ID scheme was discussed. It was outlined that the scheme is accepted by multiple organisations, and ties into the 'OPEN' movement, in that it is an Open Researcher ID, a 16 digit DOI for researchers if you will. The aim is to eliminate name ambiguities, increase the discoverablility of research and researchers, and reduce the amount of data entry needed. SFI will require ORCID ID's from next year. 

It was suggested that perhaps batch registering could be considered for organisations. 

There is currently no ID vetting on ORCID, not validating that people are who they say they are. 

Wednesday, 26 March 2014

Open Source Software for libraries: feel the fear and do it anyway. - LIR presentation

Here is the Prezi from my LIR presentation... it is also available from http://prezi.com/bmmktwsqmf3a/?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=copy. 

I am giving you the url as the embed code from Prezi think's it's optional to show the content...

Attendees who identified themselves as OSS users



Note that all the videos start to play when you access it for the first time, so go for a break while it downloads, or you will be very confused.